Garner’s writing is salutary; if you’re heartsick or world-weary, you’ll feel better after a few pages of it ... So it was surprising to drop into Stories and find myself confronted with a different Garner: coarser, colder, and dismayingly hemmed in by the short form ... Closer to outlines or character sketches than to fully fledged pieces of short fiction ... Those written in the first person are typically far more successful than those written in the third ... The 'I' restores a thrilling specificity lost elsewhere in Stories. Our faith in her candor is renewed. Insight, wisdom, her sharp wit—all seem wrestled out of long experience, hard-won rather than engineered.
Read Full Review >>