Probing ... Blending legal analysis of cases such as Korematsu and a handful of others with short profiles of the members of the court, Sloan probes the justices’ motivations and shortcomings as he examines the institution’s inner workings ... While Sloan makes a compelling case, additional context illuminating the broader history of the judicial branch would have painted a more complete picture of the justices’ actions ... FDR’s friendships with the justices, though problematic, appear more benign than Sloan’s portrayal. What Sloan adeptly explores, however, is the key question of whether the president swayed the justices to rule in his favor ... More convincing when attributing the court’s uneven legacy to wartime hysteria ... Sloan’s thoughtful book will better prepare the nation.
Read Full Review >>