Clings insistently to the superficial ... Hewitt has a fondness for lyrical description, particularly of the natural world ... These passages effectively stir up an aura of misty poignancy, but they are deployed with such frequency and at such cloying length that at times it seems like Hewitt’s goal is merely to conjure an exquisite atmosphere, rather than to understand these characters or to imbue their story with any emotional weight ... While the novel is full of beautiful surfaces, it never gives these boys any sense of particularity; we don’t know what draws them to each other. This is the problem with unrelenting rapture: It can become generic and impersonal, even solipsistic ... This is sentimental without communicating actual sentiment, airy without ever taking flight.
Read Full Review >>